Percy and Percy occupies a Hargreaves Street address that ran as Percy Watts' grocery in the 1920s, then Percy Forbes' milk bar into the 1980s. Elisha and Dan took the site on in 2012, naming the café for both men and folding milk-bar and grocer details into the fit-out. The kitchen turns Central Victorian produce into Melbourne-style brunch, with meat from Flora Hill Quality Meats and pastries from Castlemaine's Peddling Pastry.